Napheesa Collier is an unrestricted free agent this winter, free to sign with any team that she likes.
The former MVP runner-up and Defensive Player of the Year could elect to stay with the only WNBA franchise she has ever known, re-signing with the Minnesota Lynx. They were the No. 1 seed last year and have Rookie of the Year phenom point guard Olivia Miles.
If she decides to leave, however, a number of teams would be lining up to recruit her. And of those teams, it is hard to look past the powerful sales pitch that the Golden State Valkyries have.
If Collier leaves the Lynx, she just might head to the reigning champs.
Collier makes a lot of sense for Golden State
The Valkyries just won the WNBA Finals, but that does not mean they are going to sit back and merely maintain their current roster. They have a significant need for an on-ball creator and scorer; Gabby Williams cannot do it all, and no one else on the team consistently stepped up into that role. With another offensive star, the Valkyries may not have needed seven games to take down the Atlanta Dream.
Collier would fill that need perfectly, and her interior scoring ability would complement Williams and the Valkyries' shooters extremely well. Napheesa is also a knockdown shooter who could space the court from the outside to give Veronica Burton space to attack the rim. On offense, she would fit like a glove.
Better yet, she would further enhance, rather than take away from, Golden State's league-leading defense. Collier is an active defender who can take on bigs or destroy passing lanes with her quick hands. Whereas some offensive stars like Kelsey Mitchell and Kelsey Plum would become defensive liabilities, Collier is a defensive star as well.
That's why the Valkyries need her - but that's not the only pitch they have for her.
Golden State makes a lot of sense for Collier
The question hanging over Collier's future is whether she can manage her recurring ankle injuries and get back to superstar form. If she wants the WNBA organization best equipped to extend and maximize her career, she wants the Valkyries.
Owner Joe Lacob invested in their facilities at the highest level, sharing with the Warriors when appropriate and giving world-class services to the Valkyries as needed. It is a template for other WNBA teams to follow, a competitive advantage and the right thing to do.
What's more, because of that connection to the Warriors, the same medical staff that helped Stephen Curry manage his ankle injuries can help Collier do the same. After multiple ankle injuries impacted the early years of his career, they have hardly been an issue as Curry won two MVPs, four titles, and is extending the prime of his career into his late 30s.
Joining another surefire contending team would mean becoming the second or third option. The Las Vegas Aces or New York Liberty have established frontcourt stars; Collier could play alongside either A'ja Wilson or Breanna Stewart, as she does on Team USA, but she would be in their shadow even more than if she remained with Olivia Miles.
In Golden State there is an ensemble cast, with Gabby Williams as the top option but not a gravitational superstar. She and Williams could be the co-stars at the top, with a team of players comfortable filling their roles around them. She could reasonably lead the team in scoring and still be a top-tier title contender, allowing her to impact the game at the highest level and compete for a championship.
If Collier is going to leave Minnesota, we would need to be compelled to do so by the perfect situation. Golden State offers that: world-class facilities and staff, a championship coach and roster, and an opening for a two-way star.
Is that enough to convince her to leave?
